Revisit: Stacked PickleAuthor: indianapoliseater | Filed under: Food Reviews, Location: Fishers, IN
[Pic quality is a little lacking; it was dark in there and the iPhone 4 did not like that.]
11621 Fishers Station Drive
Fishers, Indiana 46038
This is our second review of the Stacked Pickle. The first one was done by wibia and was for the Carmel location. This one is for the newly opened Fishers location. I was there on a recent Saturday night for my first visit ever and was anxious to try it out.
What I Got: Burger & Wing Combo; $9.49 (it was on special that night, so usual price is $10.49). The combo is made up of the burger of your choosing off the menu (I chose the Black & Bleu burger), four wings of any flavor (I chose teriyaki) and fries.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: I love blue cheese. Because of this, the Black & Bleu burger had my name written all over it for my menu selection. I ordered it medium rare and at first glance, it appeared that they kitchen did an excellent job cooking it to that temperature because you could still see some of the juices seeping out. That was definitely a check in the positive column. Also on the outward appearance side, the burger was served with two nice sized slices of bacon and a heaping of blue cheese. If this was a burger beauty contest, this one was performing well so far. So, how did it taste? I would definitely say well above average. It was quite good in fact. It was meaty, cooked perfectly and served with just the right amount of toppings (toppings also included lettuce, tomato and onion). With its size, I would have been happy with just this burger for dinner, but since I don’t like wasting food, it was on to the wings!
First glace at the wings was telling me that these guys do not serve you skimpy wings and I LOVE it when businesses do that because it means that they care about not screwing their customers over and charging high prices for tiny wings (I’m looking at you Buffalo Wild Wings). As for the taste, the teriyaki was just okay. It wasn’t spicy and it wasn’t sweet, but it was somewhere in between. I was expecting either spicy or sweet and when I didn’t get that, I was disappointed. Still, these were tasty wings and I would not discourage anyone from ordering them.
The fries were just typical fries. It was a nice sized portion, but they were nothing to write home about. As you can see from my photo and from previous reviews where I’ve been busted for it, I rarely treat fries as anything other than ketchup delivery vehicles and these did the trick for that.
Would I Buy It Again? Yes to this combo and yes to the Stacked Pickle. This was a healthy amount of food and one special, it was a great price and value too. Even at the regular price of $10.49, I still think this is a good value and a good buy, so go for it.
This was also a nice establishment with walls full of televisions and sports memorabilia. It’s non-smoking all day and kid friendly until 10:00 p.m. on Saturdays (not sure about other days), so you can take the family here for some grub and a game. They have bands or DJs on the weekend and are open until 2:00 a.m. on those days, so if you are looking for a late night hang out, this could be an option for you too.